How to Spend 4 Days in New York City During Christmas

As someone who’s spent countless Christmases in New York City (thanks to my Italian-American family living in Brooklyn), I know firsthand how magical this time of year can be. From the twinkling lights on Fifth Avenue to the festive markets and famous ice-skating rinks, there’s a certain enchantment that takes over the city. But with so much to see and do, especially if it’s your first time, it can be a little overwhelming to plan! That’s why I’ve created the perfect 4-day itinerary to help you soak up the best aspects of Christmas in NYC.

Whether you’re strolling through Central Park, admiring window displays on Fifth Avenue, or enjoying a warm drink at one of the cozy cafes, this 4-day Christmas in NYC guide will cover it all. I’ll also be sharing tips and tricks I’ve picked up over the years to make your trip stress-free, affordable, and full of holiday spirit. So, get ready to dive into the festive whirlwind of New York during the holiday season!

Are you planning your trip to NYC last minute?

Let me help you!
Here you will find at a glance my favorite activities, tours, hotels and more.
Everything you will need to make this unforgettable!

Top Activities and Tours in NYC:
1. New York Summit One Vanderbilt Experience
2. 9/11 Memorial and Museum
3. Statue of Liberty & Ellis Island
4. American Museum of Natural History
5. New York CityPass
6. Downtown and Statue of Liberty Sightseeing Cruise

Click to search the best (updated) deals to rent a car!

Our Favorite Hotels in NYC:
1. The Ritz Carlton
2. The Knickerbocker
3. 1Hotel Central Park
4. Lotte New York Palace
5. Pod 39

Day 1: Welcome to NYC – The Classics

Welcome to New York City!
The moment you step off the plane, you can feel the holiday spirit buzzing in the air.
Not that you won’t feel it while flying. This is the best time of the year for me because flights are all about those Christmas classic songs!

The airport will also treat you to Christmas carols playing in the background.
As soon as you step in New York City, the festive decorations will make one thing clear.
Immediately.
You’re about to embark on a holiday adventure that’s nothing short of magical.

Let’s dive into your first day exploring the classic holiday landmarks that make Christmas in NYC so special. 

I’ll keep it simple but filled with must-see sights that will get you right into the Christmas spirit.

You can add or remove each activity. This has to be your holiday trip and you have to be 100% satisfied!
See it as a nice list of authentic tips for visiting New York City at Christmas coming from my experience. Hopefully you’ll love them. If not, by all means, tailor this itinerary on your needs!

1. Rockefeller Center: The Ultimate Christmas Icon

Your first stop has to be Rockefeller Center, home to the most famous Christmas tree in the world.
Trust me, even if you’ve seen it in photos or movies a hundred times, nothing beats seeing it in person!

The enormous tree, decked out in thousands of twinkling lights, stands tall against the backdrop of the iconic Rockefeller Plaza. It’s a sight that will have you snapping pictures from every angle.
Bonus points if you read my NYC in winter packing guide and you brought Christmas props for your photos!

Here’s how to make the most of your visit:

• Best Time to Visit: Go in the late afternoon so you can see it during the day and then again when it’s lit up at night—it’s like seeing two different trees!
• Ice Skating at The Rink: If you’re feeling brave, take a spin on the ice at The Rink, right below the tree. It’s the perfect way to kick off your Christmas in NYC. You can rent skates there, but keep in mind the lines can be very long, so if you’re eager to skate, consider booking a session in advance online.

Pro Tip: Grab a hot chocolate from a nearby café (there’s a Pret A Manger right there) and just take it all in. This is your moment!

2. Fifth Avenue: Holiday Window Wonderland

After you’ve soaked in the magic of Rockefeller Center, it’s time to wander up Fifth Avenue, which during Christmas feels like a festive wonderland. 
It’s by far one of the best places in New York where I love to stay at Christmas.

The famous department stores, including Saks Fifth Avenue, Bergdorf Goodman, and Macy’s, go all out with their holiday window displays. 

Think intricate designs, twinkling lights, and scenes that look like they’ve been pulled straight out of a winter fairytale.
The only other time in my life I saw that many lights was when I visited London at Christmas.

• Must-See Displays: Start at Saks Fifth Avenue—their light show on the building’s facade is a real showstopper, with music and lights choreographed into a dazzling display. Then make your way up Fifth Avenue, stopping to marvel at the creative displays in other store windows.

Pro Tip: If the crowds are heavy during the day (as they usually are), come back in the evening. The lights are even more magical after dark, and there’s something extra special about seeing them with fewer people around.
But maybe it’s just me. I firmly believe that crowds always spoil all the fun!

3. St. Patrick’s Cathedral: A Peaceful Escape

Just across from Rockefeller Center, you’ll find St. Patrick’s Cathedral, a stunning Gothic-style church that offers a peaceful respite from the hustle and bustle of Fifth Avenue.

Whether you’re religious or not, stepping inside the cathedral is like stepping into a serene oasis.
The soaring ceilings, intricate stained glass windows, and warm glow of candles create a calming atmosphere that’s especially welcome during the holiday season.

I always stop by whenever I visit NYC. I just can’t help myself. St. Patrick’s Cathedral is gorgeous and I can never get enough!

• Why It’s Worth a Visit: It’s not just a place of worship; it’s also an architectural masterpiece. Take a quiet moment to sit down, light a candle, or simply admire the beautiful details inside. You won’t regret it!

4. Radio City Music Hall: Christmas Spectacular

Next up, get ready for a show! 

Radio City Music Hall, just a short walk from Rockefeller Center, is home to the Christmas Spectacular starring the legendary Rockettes. 
You can click here to preorder your ticket: they sell out fast!

This high-energy performance is filled with dancing, music, and incredible costumes, and it’s a true holiday tradition in NYC. 

The show runs several times a day, so try to snag tickets for an afternoon or evening performance.

• What to Expect: The Rockettes’ precision dancing is the highlight. Especially for the Christmas Spectacular. But you’ll also see scenes like Santa flying across the stage, a massive Christmas tree lighting up, and a living nativity. It’s an experience that’s fun for all ages and is sure to get you in the festive mood.

Pro Tip: If you can’t catch a show, at least swing by to snap a photo in front of the iconic Radio City Music Hall marquee—it’s beautifully decorated for the holidays.
Consider it one of the must-see instagrammable spots in New York City for Christmas!

5. Wrap Up Your First Day with a Cozy Dinner

After a full day of sightseeing, you’ll probably be ready for a delicious meal.
Luckily, you’re in New York City, where dining options are endless! 

Since we’re going for the classic holiday feel, here are my two suggestions:

• The Bryant Park Grill: Located in Bryant Park, which is also home to a gorgeous Christmas market, this restaurant has a cozy, upscale vibe and delicious seasonal dishes. It’s the perfect place to warm up and reflect on your day.
• Rolf’s German Restaurant: If you’re really into Christmas décor (like, really into it, just like me), head over to Rolf’s. This little German spot is famous for going all out with holiday decorations—think thousands of ornaments, twinkling lights, and garlands. It’s a bit touristy but oh-so-festive: you will love it!

First-Timer Tip: If you’re looking for something more casual, grab a slice of classic New York pizza at Joe’s Pizza on Carmine Street—it’s iconic, delicious, and perfect after a long day of walking.

NYC Couple Trip Tip: Not many know about it but there’s a super romantic holiday cruise you can book for a special night with your significant other! It includes Christmas Carols, hot cocoa, sightseeing and romance galore. You can click here to check it out and pre-book. And if you go… maybe you’ll want to check out my guide to the top NYC Matching Couple Outfits!

Day 2: Skating, Shopping, and Shows

Rise and shine—Day 2 in NYC is here, and it’s packed with more holiday fun! 

Today, we’re diving into three quintessential New York City experiences: ice skating, shopping for Christmas souvenirs at festive markets, and catching a Broadway show. 

Get ready for a day that’s all about embracing that classic Christmas-in-the-city magic, with plenty of opportunities to make memories (and snag a few gifts for your loved ones).
Let’s go!

1. Ice Skating at Central Park: A Winter Wonderland

What’s more magical than ice skating in Central Park during the holidays?
This is your moment to feel like you’re in a Christmas movie, gliding across the ice surrounded by trees dusted with snow and the city skyline in the background.

Head to Wollman Rink, one of the most iconic ice skating spots in the park.
It’s a picture-perfect location that will give you all the holiday feels. 

You can rent skates right there, and even if you’re not the best skater, it’s all about having fun and soaking in the atmosphere.
Trust me. I’m a super awkward ice skater so I know what I’m saying!

• Best Time to Go: Mornings tend to be less crowded, so aim to get there when it opens. You’ll have more space to enjoy the ice without bumping into others!
• Pro Tip: If Central Park’s rink is too busy for your liking, another great option is the Bryant Park Winter Village skating rink. It’s free (just rent skates), and it’s nestled in the middle of a Christmas market—perfect for hopping off the ice and right into shopping mode.

2. Holiday Shopping at Festive Markets

Now that you’ve worked up an appetite and holiday spirit, it’s time to hit one of New York’s many Christmas markets. 

These markets are not just about shopping—they’re a full festive experience with twinkling lights, cozy food stalls, and unique gifts you won’t find anywhere else.
A bit like the Christmas markets in Italy I told you about, especially Bressanone, Bolzano and Brunico.

Start at Bryant Park’s Winter Village, which is home to over 150 vendors selling handmade crafts, jewelry, holiday décor, and more. 

There’s also a skating rink (if you didn’t make it to Central Park), and plenty of NYC food options to keep you fueled as you browse. 

Grab a cup of hot apple cider or try some roasted chestnuts while you wander through the stalls.

• Best Finds: Look for unique, handcrafted gifts like artisanal candles, quirky ornaments, and cozy winter accessories. It’s the perfect place to find thoughtful gifts for friends and family—or to treat yourself!
• Other Markets: If you have time, check out the Union Square Holiday Market. It has a more local, artsy vibe with indie vendors offering one-of-a-kind items. It’s a great spot to find something truly special.

Pro Tip: Keep your eyes peeled for free samples! Many vendors offer tastes of holiday treats like cookies or hot chocolate. I was lucky enough and one time I found a lovely lady selling handmade soaps who offered a ton of free samples. I loved them so much that the following day I went and bought a bunch as Christmas presents for my family back home!

3. Afternoon Break: Sweet Treats & Hot Drinks

After a morning of skating and shopping, it’s time to rest your feet and enjoy a cozy break. New York is full of holiday-themed cafés and bakeries, so find a spot to indulge in something sweet. 

My recommendation?
Dominique Ansel Bakery, where you can try their famous “Frozen S’mores” or warm up with a cup of their rich hot chocolate. It’s a nice way to slow down and recharge before your next adventure.
I mean… What kind of Christmas would it be without a cup of hot chocolate? Right?

4. Catching a Broadway Show: Holiday Magic on Stage

The afternoon is the perfect time to dive into one of New York’s most iconic experiences—a Broadway show. 

During the holidays, there are a few special performances that capture the magic of the season.
Here are some top picks:

• The Radio City Christmas Spectacular: If you missed it on Day 1, this show with the Rockettes is a must-see. It’s filled with high-kicking dancers, festive music, and a living nativity scene that brings the holidays to life on stage.
• A Christmas Carol: This timeless holiday classic is often staged in a way that’s both heartwarming and visually stunning. The tale of Scrooge and his Christmas transformation never gets old, and it’s a wonderful option if you want a traditional holiday story.
• Frozen: The Broadway Musical: If you’re visiting with kids (or if you’re just a Disney fan), “Frozen” is a magical choice. It’s full of stunning effects, memorable songs, and plenty of holiday vibes.

Pro Tips: Broadway shows can sell out fast, especially around Christmas. If you haven’t pre-booked tickets, check the TKTS booth in Times Square for same-day discounts on many shows. It’s a great way to score a last-minute seat without breaking the bank. I tried it a few times and it always saved the day!

Another very easy way to save on Broadway tickets is to get a New York City Pass.
We used it on our first trip to NYC. 

It includes 5 free iconic attractions and a ton of discounts and coupons you can use on Broadway shows and also other NYC attractions, as well as cruises and the likes. Super convenient, for our experience.
Check it out by clicking here. 

5. End the Day with Dinner and a View

After the show, it’s time to wind down with a delicious meal.
Head to The Smith near Lincoln Center for hearty American classics in a warm, inviting setting. 

If you’re in the mood for something a little more festive, try Serra by Birreria at Eataly—a rooftop restaurant decked out with holiday decorations and serving Italian comfort food.
Oh, yes. I’m totally biased here!

First-Timer Tip: If you have some energy left after dinner, take a nighttime stroll through Times Square. It’s not particularly Christmassy, but the lights and buzz of the city are a must-see, especially when the holiday crowds thin out late in the evening.
You’ll feel like stepping into a movie!

Day 3: Brooklyn Charm & More Christmas Lights

After two days of exploring Manhattan’s holiday magic, it’s time to venture across the river and experience the unique charm of Brooklyn during Christmastime. 

Again, I must confess I’m biased.
Yet Brooklyn is probably my favorite part of NYC. I have family here, and maybe that’s why. But it’s more than that. I always feel right at home whenever I step out of the metro in Brooklyn. While the Fifth is super modern, this is the part of New York City that seems to stubbornly refuse changes. 

Zia always said that some buildings and some streets feel the same as over 50 years ago when she moved there from Napoli!

Today, you’ll get a taste of local vibes, stunning views, and one of the most famous Christmas light displays in all of New York.
Brooklyn’s slower pace, artistic neighborhoods, and tight-knit communities give it a warm, cozy feel—perfect for a festive day.

Once you go, let me know if you’ve loved it as much as me!

1. Start Your Day in Brooklyn Heights

Kick off your day by heading to Brooklyn Heights, one of the borough’s most picturesque neighborhoods.
With its tree-lined streets, brownstone houses, and views of the Manhattan skyline, this area feels like stepping into a postcard. 

During Christmas, many of the homes are beautifully decorated with wreaths, garlands, and twinkling lights, adding to the festive atmosphere.

• Brooklyn Heights Promenade: Take a walk along the promenade for breathtaking views of Manhattan, the Statue of Liberty, and the Brooklyn Bridge. It’s a peaceful spot to start your morning. You can also snap some stunning photos with the skyline as your backdrop.
• Montague Street: After your stroll, head over to Montague Street, where you’ll find charming cafés and bakeries to grab a warm coffee or pastry. Tazza is a local favorite, with great coffee and cozy seating to relax before your next adventure.

2. Explore DUMBO: Cobblestones & Skyline Views

From Brooklyn Heights, it’s a short walk to DUMBO (Down Under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass), one of Brooklyn’s trendiest neighborhoods. 

Known for its cobblestone streets, industrial vibe, and stunning views of the Manhattan Bridge, DUMBO is a must-see during your visit.

• Time for Photos: The iconic spot where you can see the Manhattan Bridge perfectly framed between buildings on Washington Street is a popular photo op—especially with the holiday decorations sprinkled around the neighborhood.
• Empire Stores & Jane’s Carousel: While you’re in DUMBO, stop by Empire Stores, a beautifully restored warehouse full of shops and cafés. Nearby is Jane’s Carousel, a restored 1922 merry-go-round inside a glass pavilion that looks extra charming in the winter. If you’re up for it, take a ride—it’s pure nostalgia and fun!

Pro Tip: DUMBO has some of the best pizza spots in Brooklyn, so if you’re craving a classic slice, check out Juliana’s or Grimaldi’s for lunch. Both are iconic and serve up some of the best coal-fired pizza in the city.
Nope, not going to claim it’s like Neapolitan pizza, but I actually like them a lot!

3. Afternoon Stroll in Prospect Park

After exploring DUMBO, head to Prospect Park, Brooklyn’s answer to Central Park. 

While it’s not decked out with the holiday lights you’ll find elsewhere, Prospect Park has a quieter, more relaxed atmosphere that makes for a peaceful afternoon stroll. 

If it’s snowed recently, the park’s rolling hills and scenic paths look like something out of a winter wonderland.

4. Dyker Heights Christmas Lights: The Main Event

Now for the grand finale of your day—the Dyker Heights Christmas Lights. 

This Brooklyn neighborhood is famous for its over-the-top Christmas light displays, where homeowners go all out with thousands of lights, giant inflatable Santas, animatronics, and full-blown holiday scenes.
It’s truly something you have to see to believe!

• What to Expect: The displays cover multiple blocks, centered around 11th to 13th Avenues and 83rd to 86th Streets. Most of the houses compete to outdo each other, with some homeowners spending months preparing their decorations. There’s music, moving figures, and even “snow” falling from machines set up by some of the homes.
• Best Time to Visit: Arrive just after sunset to see the lights at their best. The streets can get crowded, so be prepared to walk slowly, but that’s part of the fun—everyone is there to enjoy the festive atmosphere together.

Pro Tip: Many companies offer bus tours to Dyker Heights, but you can also take the D train to 79th Street and walk about 15 minutes to reach the heart of the action. If you prefer a more local experience, walk through at your own pace and take it all in.

5. End Your Day with Dinner in Bay Ridge

After soaking in the dazzling lights of Dyker Heights, head to Bay Ridge, a nearby neighborhood known for its great restaurants and laid-back vibe.
It’s the perfect spot to grab dinner and unwind after a day full of exploring.

• Italian Feast: Since you’re in Brooklyn, you might as well indulge in some classic Italian food. Gino’s is a popular spot in Bay Ridge, offering delicious pasta, pizza, and traditional Italian fare. It’s warm, welcoming, and the perfect way to end your Brooklyn day.

First-Timer Tip: Make sure to bring cash for small local spots, especially in Bay Ridge, where many family-owned restaurants may not accept cards.

Are you a Swiftie like me?
Then consider going to Coney Island to end your day visiting one of Taylor’s favorite spots in New York.
Of course, do that while listening to her music!

Day 4: Cozy Cafes, Museums, and Farewell

Your final day in New York City has arrived, but there’s still plenty of time to enjoy the last bit of holiday magic before you head home. 

Today, we’re slowing down the pace and focusing on the cozier, more laid-back side of the city. 

From quaint cafés to world-class museums, this day will leave you feeling both enriched and relaxed.
After all, New York City tends to be a bit overwhelming (especially to your feet). So I always try to make sure to find enough time to rest and relax.

Let’s make the most of your last hours in NYC!

1. Start with Breakfast at a Cozy Café

There’s no better way to ease into the day than by starting with a leisurely breakfast at one of New York’s many cozy cafés. 

For a true New York experience, head to Buvette in the West Village.
This charming French-inspired spot is perfect for a relaxed, cozy breakfast. 

The warm, rustic interior, complete with wooden tables and twinkling lights, makes it feel like you’re dining in a small European bistro.

• What to Order: The waffles with fruit and a cappuccino are a must-try, or if you’re feeling indulgent, go for the croque madame. Pair it with a hot coffee or a festive spiced latte for the perfect start to your day.
• Alternative Option: If Buvette is a bit too busy, try Blue Bottle Coffee nearby. Known for its minimalist vibe and amazing coffee, it’s a great spot to grab a pastry and sip your drink while reflecting on your trip.

2. A Morning at The Met: Art & Culture

After breakfast, make your way to the Metropolitan Museum of Art (The Met). 

The Met is not only one of the world’s most renowned museums, but during the holiday season, it’s even more special thanks to its famous Christmas Tree and Neapolitan Baroque Creche display. 

The massive tree, adorned with delicate angels, stands in the Medieval Sculpture Hall and is surrounded by an 18th-century Nativity scene.

I tend to visit the artisans at Via San Gregorio Armeno in Naples (Christmas Alley) quite often. Hence why whenever I’m in NYC for the holidays I make sure to go see The Met.
It feels like home away from home: the Nativity scene is just what I’m used to seeing a lot here in Napoli!

• What to See: In addition to the Christmas tree, explore a few of The Met’s highlights, like the Temple of Dendur, an ancient Egyptian temple set in a room with floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking Central Park. You don’t need to rush—just pick a few exhibits that interest you most and take your time.
• Pro Tip: Admission is pay-what-you-wish for New York residents, but for non-residents, tickets are around $30. If you want to avoid crowds, arrive early when it opens.

3. Central Park Winter Walk

After spending the morning indoors, head across the street to Central Park for a refreshing winter walk. There’s something magical about the park in winter—whether the ground is covered in snow or the trees are still glowing with the last bits of autumn color, it’s a peaceful escape from the busy streets.

• What to Do: Wander through the park’s winding paths, stopping by iconic spots like Bow Bridge, Bethesda Terrace, and the Alice in Wonderland statue. If the weather is chilly, grab a hot drink from one of the park’s vendors and take a seat by the Loeb Boathouse to watch the ducks swim on the lake.

First-Timer Tip: Central Park is huge, so it’s best to choose a few specific areas to explore. You can easily spend a couple of hours getting lost in its beauty, but don’t forget there’s more to see today!

4. Lunch at the Upper West Side’s Jacob’s Pickles

Once you’ve worked up an appetite from your park stroll, head to the Upper West Side for lunch at Jacob’s Pickles, a cozy restaurant known for its Southern comfort food.
The warm, laid-back vibe makes it the perfect spot to relax and enjoy a hearty meal before continuing your day.

• What to Order: Try the fried chicken biscuit sandwiches, the mac & cheese, or their famous pickles (of course!). Their portions are generous, so come hungry! This spot is also great for sharing dishes if you want to try a few different things.

5. Wrap Up with the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA)

For your last cultural stop, visit the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA). It’s home to some of the most iconic modern artworks in the world, including pieces by Van Gogh, Picasso, and Warhol. 

The museum’s light-filled spaces and striking displays are a perfect contrast to The Met’s traditional elegance, giving you a full spectrum of New York’s art scene.

• Must-See Works: Don’t miss Van Gogh’s “Starry Night”, Monet’s Water Lilies, and Andy Warhol’s Campbell’s Soup Cans. Even if you’re not a huge modern art fan, MoMA’s collections are accessible and thought-provoking, making it a great way to end your trip on a high note.

6. A Final Coffee & Farewell

Before heading to the airport or catching your train, treat yourself to one last coffee break. 

Head to Birch Coffee, a quiet spot near MoMA that’s perfect for reflecting on your trip. The cozy seating and relaxed ambiance will give you a moment to unwind and savor your final moments in the city.

• What to Order: Their chai latte or maple cortado is a festive pick, or if you’re craving something sweet, try one of their freshly baked cookies.

Whether it’s your first time in the Big Apple or you’re already in love with the city’s festive spirit, this trip will leave you with memories to last a lifetime. 

So bundle up, soak in the magic, and get ready to fall in love with New York City at Christmas time!
Merry Christmas – Buon Natale!

Pin it for later!